Budget Storm Sweeps the EU: Tough Choices Between Austerity, Defense, and Aid to Ukraine

On November 21, European Council President António Costa unveiled a new draft long-term budget for the EU covering the period 2028–2034. Calculated in 2025 constant prices, the total seven-year budget has been reduced to €1.582 trillion—a cut of approximately €20.4 billion (about 10%) compared to the initial proposal by the European Commission, which had suggested nearly €2 trillion.

To secure broader support, Costa’s revised proposal relatively preserves funding for agriculture and regional cohesion, while shifting the bulk of cuts toward the "European Competitiveness Fund" (aimed at enhancing industrial competitiveness), defense spending, and external assistance programs.

Compared to the compromise proposal put forward by Ireland during its presidency in October, Costa’s version actually offers greater protection for agricultural and regional cohesion funds. Defense expenditure remains one of the primary targets for reduction under the new framework.

In its original proposal in July 2025, the European Commission had planned to increase budgets for defense, security, and space to roughly five times the previous level—amounting to €13.1 billion.

The release of Costa’s draft immediately triggered strong internal backlash across the EU. France and the European Parliament expressed significant dissatisfaction. France argued that the new proposal provides insufficient support for the Common Agricultural Policy; the European Parliament’s chief budget negotiator criticized the approach as “cut after cut” rather than a coherent investment strategy, deeming it unacceptable. Meanwhile, net contributor countries such as Germany maintained that the proposed reductions fall short of necessary fiscal discipline.

Regarding aid to Ukraine, Costa’s draft fully retains a dedicated €100 billion fund for Ukraine, positioned outside the main budget ceiling.

The intense negotiations over overall budget size, allocation priorities, and responsibility for supporting Ukraine reveal deep-seated geopolitical divisions within the EU.

1. The “Fiscal Prudence Bloc” (centered on Germany): Fiscal Restraint Linked to Geopolitical Responsibility

Represented by Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, and Austria—net contributor states—this group prioritizes controlling national fiscal burdens and pushing for a fundamental reorientation of EU fiscal discipline.

Germany (the largest net contributor): German Chancellor Friedrich Merz took a firm stance, asserting that the proposed cuts remain insufficient. Germany’s strategic calculus extends beyond cost-saving; it seeks to reshape burden-sharing mechanisms. Merz explicitly tied Germany’s support for the long-term budget to a commitment from all member states to share the financial burden of Ukraine aid equally—particularly addressing the projected €70 billion shortfall by 2027. Berlin aims to leverage its veto power to counter perceived free-riding by certain Central and Eastern European states, while redirecting resources toward defense and economic competitiveness, rather than traditional agricultural subsidies.

The Netherlands and Nordic States: Countries like Sweden described the proposed budget expansion as “entirely unacceptable,” while the Netherlands emphasized that the budget must focus exclusively on security and competitiveness, opposing excessive use of funds for conventional transfer payments.

2. The “Cohesion Allies” (centered on France, Spain, Italy): Defending Core Interests and Strategic Autonomy

Comprising southern European nations and parts of Central and Eastern Europe, this bloc resists substantial cuts to agricultural and regional development funding, fearing that fiscal tightening would undermine domestic priorities and weaken Europe’s strategic autonomy.

France: As the largest beneficiary of the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), France reacted most strongly to the new draft. The presidential office described the proposal as “deeply disappointing,” arguing it fails to ensure farmers’ incomes and cannot serve as a foundation for agreement. France’s underlying concern lies in maintaining core sectors—agriculture and industrial competitiveness—as essential pillars of national and European strategic autonomy amid ongoing geopolitical uncertainty. These elements, including support for the European Competitiveness Fund in response to competition with China and the United States, are viewed as non-negotiable.

Spain and Italy: Spain advocates expanding the overall budget to address multiple concurrent crises and has proposed deferring repayment of pandemic-era recovery fund debt to free up resources. Italy demands the elimination of budgetary rebates currently granted to countries like Germany, insisting that if such benefits exist, they should apply reciprocally.

3. The Central and Eastern European “Anti-Aid to Ukraine” Bloc (Hungary, Slovakia, Czech Republic, etc.): Sovereignty First, Cost Avoidance

This faction plays a disruptive role in budget negotiations, grounded in a prioritization of domestic welfare and energy security over external geopolitical commitments.

Rejection of Shared Burden for Ukraine Aid: Hungary and Slovakia strongly oppose Germany’s attempt to link Ukraine aid financing with the EU budget. Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico explicitly stated his country will not participate in large-scale grants to Ukraine, while Hungary opposes tying aid to long-term budgetary decisions.

Energy and Domestic Welfare Considerations: Affected by the fallout from the Russia-Ukraine conflict and retaliatory sanctions, these countries face persistently high energy prices and elevated inflation. Their primary concerns center on employment, inflation control, and social welfare. They warn that increased support for Ukraine risks crowding out investments in green transition and domestic social spending, potentially fueling domestic populist backlash.

4. The European Parliament: Conflict Between Investment Strategy and Fiscal Austerity

As a co-decision maker on the budget, the European Parliament occupies a middle ground but leans toward an investment-oriented approach. It expresses serious concern that excessive cuts to the Competitiveness Fund and defense spending would severely undermine the EU’s capacity to respond to great-power competition and emerging security challenges.

It is evident that the EU now faces a “three-account dilemma.”

This budget struggle reflects a systemic imbalance between competing imperatives: fiscal sustainability (where money comes from and how it is spent), security (support for Ukraine versus defense autonomy), and structural transformation (green transition and industrial competitiveness). Germany’s logic centers on using fiscal authority to enforce shared geopolitical responsibility—leveraging budgetary power to compel uniform contributions to Ukraine aid. France’s logic emphasizes safeguarding strategic autonomy through protection of core sectors such as agriculture and industry. The Central and Eastern European bloc, meanwhile, insists on preserving national sovereignty by rejecting costs associated with conflicts distant from their immediate interests.

At the special summit in Brussels scheduled for November 26–27, whether the bloc can achieve a fragile equilibrium among these three dimensions will determine the EU’s geopolitical trajectory and internal cohesion over the next seven years.

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882522925503499/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.