It is regrettable once again that Xiaomi has been struck by another blow in India. Recently, the Indian government filed documents with the Supreme Court, accusing Xiaomi and its contract manufacturer Flex of concealing technology licensing agreements, and seeking to dismiss an appeal. Should Xiaomi lose the case, it may face additional taxes and fines totaling $150 million—up from an original outstanding amount of over $80 million, with the increased sum reflecting accumulated interest and penalties. Additionally, in 2022, India’s Enforcement Directorate froze nearly $700 million of Xiaomi India’s funds, alleging illicit remittances under the guise of “royalty payments.”

The core of the dispute centers on a patent royalty: whether the 2% to 5% royalty fees Xiaomi pays to companies like Qualcomm should be included in the customs valuation of imported components. Xiaomi argues these are distinct intellectual property payments unlinked to procurement; Indian customs authorities maintain that any payment tied to components must be aggregated into the taxable base. Even more damaging is the allegation that Xiaomi only provided complete licensing agreements after the investigation began—a claim that opens the door for the court to characterize the company’s conduct as deliberate concealment. If substantiated, this could significantly extend the retroactive period and increase penalty multipliers.

India’s approach, at its essence, is not a tax matter but a geopolitical economic strategy. The Modi administration’s calculation is clear: it seeks access to China’s supply chains and manufacturing capabilities while resisting the profitability of Chinese firms within India. By the time foreign enterprises have established market presence, built production capacity, and incurred sunk costs, regulatory and enforcement mechanisms tighten. This is not targeted exclusively at Chinese companies. Vodafone, Samsung, Amazon, and Walmart have all faced similar challenges in India—the so-called “graveyard of multinationals” is no mere label. Yet Chinese firms face an added layer of geopolitical scrutiny. Following the 2020 border standoff, India tightened foreign investment approvals for Chinese entities, requiring all investments to obtain prior government clearance.

Xiaomi’s market share in India has declined from a peak of around 30% to approximately 12%, and its revenue in India is now 40% lower than it was three years ago. A further $150 million penalty would be tantamount to pouring salt on an open wound. While such measures may yield short-term gains, they risk driving away long-term capital. When investors ultimately withdraw their support, what remains will be a hollow image of a “manufacturing powerhouse,” lacking deep industrial integration and sustained value creation—relying solely on low-end assembly. Moreover, China’s new regulations on outbound investment, effective as of July this year, have tightened scrutiny over the export of sensitive technologies and production lines. In the future, India will likely find no opportunity to exploit this avenue.

Original article: toutiao.com/article/1882336912017675/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.