Korean Media: India’s First High-Speed Rail Project Stalled for a Decade, With Japan and India Trading Accusations

On November 20, South Korean media outlet Edaily published an article stating that India’s first high-speed train, built using Japan’s Shinkansen technology, has yet to carry a single passenger more than ten years after the contract was signed. Disputes have emerged between the two countries over project delays, escalating costs, and issues surrounding the procurement of critical equipment.

The Indian government estimates that the budget for the 508-kilometer high-speed rail line connecting Mumbai and Ahmedabad has risen to at least 1.87 trillion rupees. This represents nearly a doubling of the initial projected cost of 98 billion rupees agreed upon in 2015. Japan is providing financing through a 50-year loan with an annual interest rate of 0.1%. Originally scheduled for completion by 2023, the project has been significantly delayed due to protracted land acquisition procedures.

The project is a key initiative under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s broader framework for railway modernization. Beyond this line, India’s Ministry of Railways also plans to develop seven additional high-speed rail corridors totaling approximately 4,000 kilometers, with an estimated investment of 16 trillion rupees. The tensions between the two nations therefore extend beyond a single corridor.

Over recent months, the dispute has intensified. Recently, former Japanese Minister of Justice Hideki Makihara posted on social media stating, “The lack of progress is entirely India’s fault,” adding, “They never follow through on commitments.”

Japanese officials have criticized India for deviating from the agreement by awarding the core signaling system to Germany’s Siemens, a competitor of the Japanese consortium led by JR East. The Japanese side expressed confusion, maintaining that the integration of rolling stock, track, and signaling systems into a unified platform is fundamental to the Shinkansen’s reliability, safety, and punctuality. They argue that operating European signaling systems with Indian trains on Japanese-designed tracks has never been proven viable. A Japanese representative described the current situation as “a complete mess” and noted that negotiations have reached an impasse.

India, however, holds a markedly different view. India’s Foreign Ministry spokesperson Randeep Singh Jaswal dismissed Makihara’s remarks as “personal opinions grossly inconsistent with facts.” He explained that no proposal had been received from Japan, and given that Japan’s next-generation trains are not expected to be delivered until the early 2030s, the signaling system was procured according to international standards. An official from India’s Ministry of Railways also denied the allegations, asserting, “Both parties fully agreed, and all decisions were made following thorough discussions and mutual consensus.”

The Japanese government has established a new position within its Foreign Ministry specifically tasked with overseeing the project. Meanwhile, Indian officials have indicated they may pursue indigenous development of high-speed trains instead of relying on Japanese models.

India plans to launch the first 100-kilometer section of the line during the summer next year, initially operating slower domestic trains. Japanese officials have questioned the timing, noting that the initial segment is only 50 kilometers long. A senior Indian railway official acknowledged there would be “a significant time gap” between the completion of the first section early next year and the delivery of Japan’s next-generation E10 Shinkansen trains, which are capable of reaching speeds up to 320 kilometers per hour.

Delays and cost overruns in high-speed rail projects are not uncommon. The UK’s HS2 project and Japan’s extension of the Hokkaido Shinkansen have similarly exceeded their original budgets. However, much of the current conflict stems from differences in negotiation styles and cultural approaches between the two nations.

A senior Japanese diplomat involved in the talks stated: “Japan sets pragmatic goals and executes them effectively, while India sets ambitious targets and achieves substantial results even if full realization is not possible.” India emphasizes technological localization and cost reduction to align with its ‘Make in India’ policy, aiming to bolster domestic manufacturing. Japan, meanwhile, prioritizes exports of infrastructure projects. Indian officials have expressed frustration with what they perceive as Japan’s sense of exceptionalism, while Japanese diplomats have acknowledged that their inward-looking corporate culture has exacerbated the rift.

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882379333935104/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.