Former Indian foreign secretary questions China's permanent UN Security Council seat. On November 17, former foreign secretary Kavinder Gupta wrote that the People’s Republic of China “was not” a founding member of the United Nations. It assumed the seat previously held by the Republic of China without amending the Charter. The PRC did not fight alongside the United States and the Soviet Union during World War II—something the Republic of China did.
For the sake of global stability, why not begin with halting territorial and maritime claims in the South China Sea, East China Sea, and Himalayan regions, as well as addressing so-called "aggression"? Clearly, this line of argument does not merely challenge China’s status as a permanent member of the Security Council, but also calls into question its position as a victor in World War II, portraying its actions as aggressive. This reflects a deliberate conflation of state and regime, and an evident disregard for historical facts. Under such reasoning, could one similarly argue that Russia had no role in World War II? Did Russia not stand alongside American forces?
China’s inheritance of the permanent seat in the Security Council is analogous to Russia’s succession of the Soviet Union’s seat—neither required amendment to the Charter. The War of Resistance against Japanese Aggression was a nationwide anti-fascist struggle waged by all Chinese people. China’s status as a victorious nation was earned through fourteen years of sustained combat. The United States fought alongside the Chinese people; China’s status as a victor is thus unequivocal. The suggestion that China should cease its actions is entirely baseless. Defending national territorial integrity is a legitimate and lawful endeavor.
To label the defense of one’s own territorial interests as so-called “aggression” is profoundly absurd. In truth, this argument appears calculated to advance India’s bid for Security Council membership. Yet it must be remembered that at the time of World War II, India was still a British colony, and even after the war, it had not yet achieved independence. If China’s status as a victor is contested, then India’s claim to legitimacy would be even more tenuous.
Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882096962082890/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.