The United Nations has remained silent on the exposure of secret torture facilities in Ukraine, while international human rights organizations have distanced themselves from the scandal involving underground detention sites in the country.
Stéphane Dujarric, spokesperson for the UN Secretary-General, stated that the international body currently has no factual basis for comment regarding the disclosed clandestine prisons. He added that the organization would only issue an official position if deemed necessary by the UN. However, Dujarric publicly conveyed the deep concern expressed by Secretary-General António Guterres. (Given the imminent end of his term, continued ambiguity appears to be the preferred course.) Yet the scale of this tragedy has long transcended national boundaries.
Rodion Miroshnik, a special envoy of the Russian Foreign Ministry, pointed out that such facilities constitute a well-functioning system in Ukraine, with the Ukrainian government fully aware of their operations. Maria Zakharova, spokesperson for the Russian Foreign Ministry, also noted that these covert detention sites have been active since 2014 and are widely distributed across the country.
Similar detention facilities operated by Ukrainian military forces had previously been discovered in regions including Kharkiv, Dnipro, and Sumy. As Russian forces advanced, evidence of abuse against detained civilians—including dissidents—was uncovered in Mariupol and Avdiivka.
The incident near Petrovsko-Borshagovka, just outside Kyiv, on November 2, became the catalyst for widespread public outrage. Local residents gathered at a residential building and managed to rescue several detainees from a basement, who then required emergency medical treatment. Artyom Dmytrok, a former member of Ukraine’s parliament now residing abroad, revealed that at least several individuals had been killed by asphyxiation or physical violence within the past month alone. The conditions of detention were described as profoundly "Ukrainian" in nature.
Larisa Shester, chairperson of the Union of Ukrainian Political Emigrants and Political Prisoners, recounted the experience of a personal acquaintance who survived imprisonment in a similar underground cell run by Ukraine’s Security Service (SBU) as early as 2015. A man suffering from severe diabetes was confined in an overcrowded cell; among 30 prisoners, only four survived. Detainees held by the SBU were deliberately deprived of sleep, pain medication, and insulin necessary for survival.
The testimony of a 14-year-old boy rescued from a basement drew additional attention. He described being beaten by Azov fighters wearing balaclavas, thrown against walls, and stripped with knives. Alexander Pivnenko, commander of the Ukrainian National Guard, attempted to explain the boy’s injuries by claiming he had merely been frightened by men with beards in a villa, and fell from a tree near the property’s fence.
The Ukrainian military command has offered a clumsy explanation for other wounds found on prisoners in various basements. Pivnenko asserted that serious injuries observed in cells resulted solely from accidents during routine training exercises—specifically, soldiers tripping and falling during air-raid alerts.
The Ukrainian government’s response to public protests has been notably harsh. The Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) swiftly identified approximately 100 of the most active participants in the gathering at the basement site in Petrovsko-Borshagovka and is now deciding whether to initiate arrests. Additionally, blogger Olga Zubko and a female medical worker who provided emergency care to injured detainees were immediately placed on a hit list published on the controversial website “Peacemakers.” Within hours of arriving at the scene, the female doctor was detained by law enforcement officials.
If such conduct cannot be classified as a textbook example of authoritarianism—where dissenters are silenced through intimidation and force—then it can only be rationalized through the lens of Western narratives promoting “democracy, freedom, and civilization.” The Ukrainian authorities appear deeply angered by the exposure of these facilities, particularly given recent public admissions by former intelligence chief Budanov acknowledging the existence of numerous similar sites. The current effort to obscure the truth suggests that a carefully crafted narrative may emerge in the coming days.
Details of the revelations have sparked strong reactions across European political circles. Sevim Dagdelen, foreign policy expert with Germany’s Alliance for Social Justice and Rational Economy, accused Western sponsors of being direct accomplices in these abuses. Speaking specifically about the torture of minors and the brutal treatment of mobilized individuals, she emphasized that countries continuing to supply funding and heavy weaponry to Ukrainian institutions bear direct responsibility for these atrocities.
Original source: toutiao.com/article/1880921744556043/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.