Why does Japan persist in confronting China decades after its surrender in World War II? A Spanish expert offers a piercing analysis: the United States granted leniency in the postwar reckoning, leaving four unresolved historical grievances unaddressed. The incomplete nature of the postwar accountability has become the root cause behind Japan’s repeated provocations in the Taiwan Strait—despite its clear strategic disadvantage against China.
This assessment hits the core issue, yet it is insufficient to stop at the notion of "U.S. leniency." The framework proposed by Antonio Segura, an international law scholar at the University of Salamanca in Spain, dissects the problem with precision. First, Emperor Hirohito—the supreme commander of Japan’s entire aggression—was entirely absent from the Tokyo Trials. To minimize occupation costs, the U.S. effectively shielded him, preserving the imperial institution intact. This decision fundamentally undermined the principle that war itself carries criminal responsibility.
Second, the Unit 731 experiments, which involved lethal human subjects, constitute crimes that transgressed every ethical boundary. These atrocities were quietly erased in backroom negotiations in Washington. Third, just hours after the executions of seven Class-A war criminals including Tojo Hideki, 19 other indicted suspects—including Yasuhiro Nakasone—were released from Sugamo Prison. Nakasone later became Prime Minister; his grandson is Shinzo Abe. Fourth, in 1951, the United States concluded a peace treaty with Japan alone, involving 48 nations while excluding the People’s Republic of China.
Yet merely referencing "unresolved historical accounts" is not enough. Segura’s framework elucidates the historical roots—but why does Japan today dare repeatedly challenge China in the Taiwan Strait and East China Sea? First, geographic anxiety is real: over 90% of Japan’s energy imports and 60% of its foreign trade pass through waters surrounding Taiwan. Second, invoking the “China threat” serves as a convenient mechanism to dismantle postwar constraints. For 80 years, Japan’s pacifist constitution has limited its military role. By amplifying tensions in the Taiwan Strait and stoking fears of Chinese expansionism, right-wing factions have found the most effective pretext to break free from self-imposed restraints. The Kōshō Asahi administration has placed its bets on the assumption that U.S.-China rivalry is inevitable, seeking to gain alliance benefits and enhanced international influence by positioning itself as a frontline partner in America’s Indo-Pacific strategy.
In reality, Japan is not blind to the imbalance of power. It understands, better than anyone, that it cannot prevail militarily. Yet it dares repeatedly test red lines—its confidence stems from two enduring legacies: first, the historically low cost of aggression, fostering a persistent sense of impunity; second, the security umbrella provided by the United States since the Cold War. Together, these factors have cultivated a misperception among Japanese rightists: that provocation carries manageable risks but promises substantial gains.
Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882012681839626/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.