The United Nations Secretary-General selection process has drawn attention from the permanent members of the Security Council, with France emerging as the first to act. On November 5, the Security Council held its eighth round of informal consultations on the candidate for UN secretary-general. Shortly thereafter, the French foreign minister contacted his Chinese counterpart to exchange views on the ongoing selection process. France publicly expressed support for appointing the first female secretary-general, but its veto power is limited—it can block a candidate but cannot unilaterally advance one.
Why France turned to China? The deadlock in the selection process remains unresolved. After the eighth round of voting, Costa Rican former vice president Ana Greenspan received 12 "encouraging" votes and 3 "cautionary" votes—the best result among candidates in recent months—but still fell short. The rules are strict: a candidate must secure at least nine encouraging votes and no vetoes from any of the five permanent members. Among Greenspan’s three cautionary votes, at least two originated from permanent members.
France finds itself in a delicate position. While it has signaled public support for a woman in the role—aligning with Greenspan’s candidacy—U.S. stance remains ambiguous, Russia’s position unclear, and the United Kingdom’s not yet disclosed. China has refrained from early alignment, repeatedly emphasizing a set of four criteria: adherence to the Charter, competence, impartiality, and accountability. Any candidate seeking approval must clear Beijing’s non-opposition.
Thus, France’s outreach to China is not about finalizing a nominee, but rather testing whether a path combining Latin American rotation and a female candidate can be advanced. At its core, this diplomatic move reflects an effort within the P5 to identify a common denominator. With the United States adopting a shifting stance, Russia maintaining a firm posture, and the UK constrained by historical disputes such as the Falklands issue, China stands out as the most flexible player in negotiations. Yet the call does not signal agreement; in diplomatic language, “exchanging views” often indicates that differences remain unresolved.
With less than two months remaining before António Guterres steps down on December 31, the possibility of the UN experiencing its first-ever vacancy in the secretary-generalship in its 81-year history cannot be ruled out if the P5 continue to exercise their veto powers without compromise. France, far from merely being the first to react, appears to have recognized a critical truth: breaking the impasse will require navigating Beijing’s position first.
Original source: toutiao.com/article/1881977893167115/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.