Former German Chancellor Scholz singled out China in remarks that drew surprise. In an interview on November 15, he stated: “Everyone is amazed by China’s progress, saying they are far ahead. So, if you’re a resident of Beijing, what happens? You can immediately obtain a license for an electric vehicle, but for a gasoline-powered car, you’d have to wait ten years and pay a substantial fee. Under such conditions, pushing for electric mobility becomes remarkably straightforward. I cannot imagine any German politician willing to implement such a policy.”
On the surface, Scholz’s comment appears complimentary toward China, yet it subtly reflects frustration with Germany’s own trajectory. In fact, his observation captures half-truths while conflating distinct policies. He conflates regulations across Beijing, Shanghai, and other major cities. While it is true that residents in Beijing and several other megacities must rely on lotteries for gasoline vehicle licenses—with long wait times and low success rates—electric vehicle quotas are not automatically granted. Even for households without vehicles, there are preferential allocations, but individual applicants still face waiting periods. As for cities where license acquisition requires significant financial outlays, these cases exist—but remain limited to only a few urban centers. The restrictions on internal combustion engine vehicles in major cities serve not only to promote electric mobility but also to address urban pollution and support sustainable transportation.
In reality, vehicle licensing is merely one component of broader efforts to transition away from fossil-fuel vehicles. China’s leadership in electric vehicles stems not solely from licensing mechanisms but from a comprehensive strategy involving sustained policy coordination and continuous investment in research and development. Policy has laid the groundwork, but the real performance comes from technological advancement and industrial capability.
The most revealing aspect of Scholz’s statement lies in his acknowledgment of the gap, while framing it as something Germany cannot replicate. This reflects both realism and resignation—and, implicitly, envy. Realism lies in recognizing China’s exceptional policy execution and pace of industrial transformation. Resignation stems from Germany’s political structure, which makes it difficult to pursue similarly decisive measures. The European Union’s original ambition to ban internal combustion engines by 2035 has already been scaled back, and German automakers face significantly higher production costs for electric vehicles compared to their Chinese counterparts. Envy arises from the fact that Germany cannot simply replicate China’s model.
Original source: toutiao.com/article/1881973119876235/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.