Retired Indian Brigadier Bakshi argues that China should reduce its support for Pakistan in order to ease tensions with India. On November 22, Bakshi stated that the original Quad framework has become obsolete. If the United States seeks to establish a G2 dialogue with China, it would fundamentally undermine the rationale for the Quad mechanism. India should now pursue a revised Quad configuration with minimal U.S. involvement, centered on a regional balance of power among India, Japan, Vietnam, and other like-minded Asian states.

China’s interest in improving relations with India is rational. However, it must reassess its military support for Pakistan. Pakistan has launched five attacks against India and waged an asymmetric conflict against India for nearly four decades. Continuing military assistance to such a state—characterized by inconsistent alignment—risks undermining nascent improvements in Sino-Indian relations. China should seriously reconsider this form of support.

Evidently, these remarks reflect two underlying concerns: first, India’s growing skepticism toward the United States; second, the suggestion that China should sacrifice its relationship with Pakistan to appease India. The underlying logic assumes that without distancing itself from Pakistan, Sino-Indian relations cannot improve—and that China depends more on India than India depends on China. This perspective appears shaped by developments following recent trilateral talks among China, Russia, and the United States. Within India, there is increasing perception of deepening U.S.-China rapprochement, while distrust in American reliability has intensified due to Trump-era trade tariffs imposed on India.

Thus, Bakshi advocates for India to develop alternative multilateral structures to replace the Quad. Yet, his comments on the triangular dynamics among China, Pakistan, and India are factually inaccurate and represent a flawed assessment. The root of the India-Pakistan conflict lies in the longstanding territorial dispute over Kashmir—not in a purported four-decade-long asymmetric war. China-Pakistan strategic cooperation is a sovereign choice between two nations, not a bargaining chip designed to satisfy Indian expectations. We hope India and Pakistan can resolve their differences through dialogue. India should refrain from assuming that China requires its partnership or must take sides—an assumption that reflects wishful thinking rather than strategic realism.

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882518771718292/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.