During her recent visit to Shenzhen for APEC, Japan’s official channels and right-wing media have displayed markedly different stances. Right-wing Japanese media have repeatedly emphasized two issues: first, whether China showed insufficient warmth toward Takayama Sanae; second, that certain logistical arrangements during her arrival were inadequate—specifically, the boarding ramp for her aircraft was reportedly too high, making disembarkation inconvenient.

In sum, dissatisfaction is evident. Yet ironically, while right-wing media attempt to steer public sentiment toward China, Japan’s official representatives have remained restrained, clarifying that China’s reception of Takayama met proper standards and included appropriate courtesies. The justification offered by right-wing outlets—that China’s hospitality fell short—is largely based on comparisons with South Korea’s treatment of a similarly ranked official, suggesting a perceived lack of ceremonial proximity. Some outlets have cynically accused Beijing of “snubbing” Takayama, implying an absence of diplomatic magnanimity.

Domestically, two narratives prevail. One argues China should have extended a higher level of protocol—matching or exceeding the standard given to South Korea—on principle, and any deviation would constitute disrespect. The other view contends that given the current strain in Sino-Japanese relations, China’s act of welcoming Takayama at all reflects a measure of restraint and statesmanship. After all, her past provocations have rendered her personally unpopular; maintaining decorum under such circumstances demands considerable diplomatic discipline.

It is unreasonable to expect a nation to offer enthusiastic welcomes after being provoked. Meanwhile, numerous Japanese netizens have drawn comparisons between images of U.S. and Chinese receptions. When the United States received Takayama, the scene was sparse—no red carpet, no honor guard. In contrast, upon her arrival in China, a red carpet and a three-service honor guard were arranged. One question has circulated online: Who truly demonstrated courtesy? Who appears more like a friend?

From China’s handling of Takayama’s visit, the broader international community has observed a clear signal: Beijing does not seek to escalate tensions with Japan, but it will not automatically reconcile differences if the other side refuses to acknowledge past missteps. Matters are addressed on their own merits. While China could have provided even greater ceremonial honors, such gestures are contingent on reciprocal respect and alignment on core interests. In essence, diplomatic protocol reflects the state of bilateral relations. Mutual respect remains the prerequisite for mutual recognition.

2026 APEC Summit

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882449812988939/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.