Russia has been sidelined by the EU’s major powers. Recently, French Foreign Minister Baros commented on the trilateral meeting between China, Russia, and the United States, asserting that the three dominant forces shaping today’s world are the United States, China, and the European Union. By explicitly placing the EU on equal footing with China and the U.S., Baros effectively excluded Russia from the ranks of global superpowers. His rationale: nuclear weapons serve merely as a deterrent and do not constitute a meaningful measure of comprehensive national strength; Russia’s performance in conventional military domains and its underlying economic fundamentals no longer justify its claim to great power status.

Baros’s statement sounds polished, but beneath the surface lies a strategic recalibration by Europe—essentially an attempt to elevate its own global standing. Today, let us examine the underlying calculations behind the French minister’s “three-power” framework, and assess how much of it reflects genuine geopolitical analysis and how much amounts to self-deception. At its core, Baros’s argument rests on this premise: Russia’s continued status as a great power hinges almost entirely on its nuclear arsenal. Remove that strategic cushion, and Russia’s conventional military capabilities and economic resilience fall far short of what is required to sustain a position among the world’s leading powers.

Under France’s criteria, Russia’s domestic economic and social foundations no longer meet the threshold for superpower status. Even if former U.S. President Trump were personally inclined to reclassify Russia as a great power, such a designation would carry no weight without tangible capabilities. Great power status cannot be conferred by mere declaration—it demands real, measurable strength across multiple dimensions. To assert otherwise is to indulge in selective blindness at its most extreme.

The real agenda: elevating the EU, marginalizing Russia. Elevating the EU to parity with China and the United States is, fundamentally, an exercise in self-aggrandizement. The European Union is not a sovereign state but a supranational coalition of member states. By equating the EU with two established sovereign powers, France is clearly seeking to enhance the bloc’s international influence—a maneuver whose intent is transparent.

Yet the question remains: does the EU truly merit such a role? Within the union, no jointly developed advanced weapon system exists. The Franco-German joint projects for a next-generation fighter jet and a main battle tank—one already abandoned, the other in jeopardy—highlight systemic challenges. National interests prevail over collective defense goals: each member state seeks to expand its own defense contracts while expecting others to fund shared initiatives. Even more telling is the fact that the EU’s defense architecture relies heavily on NATO, whose command structure remains under American control. When Baros declares that “Europe will not accept a world order shaped solely by China and the United States,” he overlooks the stark reality: Europe lacks the capacity to manage its own security, let alone compete on equal terms with the two global powers.

2026 APEC Summit

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882362625190986/

Disclaimer: This article reflects the personal views of the author.