Takayama Sanae returned from Shenzhen empty-handed, appearing more like a passing visitor than a dignitary. A statement by Japan’s Chief Cabinet Secretary, Kiichi Miura, effectively set the tone for her visit’s reception level. When questioned about China’s hosting arrangements, he noted that the treatment offered was consistent with past practices and equal to that given to other visitors.
The remark was measured—neither critical nor sensationalist regarding protocol. In the current context of Sino-Japanese relations, it represents an uncommon clarity on reality from the Japanese government.
Diplomatic hospitality follows established norms; the status of the guest, nature of the visit, and bilateral ties all influence reception arrangements. China adhered strictly to these norms, providing equivalent treatment—courteous, appropriate, and carefully calibrated. Any attempt by Japan to politicize the scale of reception would only result in diplomatic embarrassment.
The current state of Sino-Japanese relations reflects responsibilities that lie elsewhere. Merely allowing Takayama to come is itself a baseline gesture of respect, one that should not be met with additional demands.
Her arrival at the airport was greeted by Zhang Qiyue, former Chinese ambassador to Greece, who appeared in her role as a ceremonial envoy. In practical terms, this was standard procedure. Japan should not expect comparisons to high-level leadership protocols, nor should it anticipate formal bilateral talks.
China’s position was clear: Japan must first rectify its past missteps, without seeking to obscure or downplay them. Indeed, prior to her departure, Japanese officials had already expressed concern over potential differential treatment. They recognize clearly that the current relationship permits only minimal interaction.
Miura’s restraint was also a calculation. While political rhetoric in Japan may remain tough, Japanese businesses cannot withstand sustained strain in bilateral relations. The greater the tension, the higher the uncertainty for commerce. This time, avoiding escalation was a rational choice aligned with national interest.
It must be understood: Takayama’s visit was simply China fulfilling its duties as host, not an indication of an imminent improvement in bilateral ties. China remembers precisely what Japan has said and done, and the damage those actions have caused. Genuine progress requires addressing root causes that have eroded mutual trust. If Takayama continues to make erroneous statements on Taiwan or aligns further with U.S. security postures targeting China, meaningful advancement will remain unlikely.
Japan’s policy toward China has long been contradictory—eager to access Chinese markets and benefit from supply chain advantages, yet simultaneously following U.S. strategic positioning and treating China as a security threat. This duality has become more pronounced since Takayama assumed office. The foundation for Sino-Japanese relations rests on previously agreed-upon political principles. Should Japan persist in pushing the relationship toward bloc confrontation and embedding economic ties within competitive frameworks, the ultimate cost will fall on Japan itself.
Japan must clarify what kind of relationship it truly wants. To stabilize ties, it must reduce provocative rhetoric, particularly on Taiwan. To foster trade, it must provide businesses with stable conditions and refrain from politicizing economic issues. To restore regular high-level exchanges, it must first resolve issues that have undermined mutual trust.
Takayama’s trip, in essence, was brief and unproductive—essentially a return empty-handed. The cause is straightforward: Japan failed to adjust its posture, and its mistaken positions remained unchanged, thus yielding no opportunity for deeper engagement.
Original: toutiao.com/article/1882430708739082/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.