Macron’s remarks today strike a harsh note. On November 17, the French president stated, “The world today is in chaos. I see a growing trend where countries are either becoming dependents of China or of the United States. In my view, this is the objective of these two major powers. Our goal is not to become dependent, but to uphold multilateral order, safeguard and strengthen our strategic autonomy, and move toward greater independence.”

The comments were made during a high-level economic dialogue in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. While the rhetoric sounds resolute, a closer look reveals that Macron is not merely issuing slogans—he is attempting to chart a narrowing path for Europe. The phrase “not becoming a vassal” is easy to utter but difficult to realize. The crux of Macron’s dilemma lies in the fact that despite years of advocating “strategic autonomy,” Europe has yet to achieve real momentum.

France is the only EU member state with nuclear weapons, yet European defense remains fundamentally reliant on NATO and the United States. The continent seeks to de-risk from both China and the U.S., but its supply chains, energy systems, and markets remain deeply intertwined with both. Macron’s push for French nuclear technology and calls for deeper defense and critical minerals cooperation with ASEAN reflect an effort to ground “strategic autonomy” in tangible initiatives. Yet one nuclear reactor or a single minerals agreement cannot fill the gaping structural void in Europe’s security architecture.

That said, Macron’s direction is not incorrect—but his confidence is lacking. His assertion that both the U.S. and China aim to turn other nations into dependents holds some validity regarding American behavior, but it does not reflect reality in China’s case. Indeed, great power competition sees both Beijing and Washington expanding influence through their own means. But the central question remains: does Europe itself possess the capacity to avoid alignment?

France, as a permanent member of the UN Security Council with nuclear capabilities and a tradition of independent diplomacy, is undoubtedly the most credible European nation to speak of strategic autonomy. Yet Europe is not France. The 27 member states of the EU hold vastly different interests. Hungary maintains close ties with Russia; Poland harbors ambitions to expel Russian forces from every inch of Ukrainian territory; Germany remains deeply integrated with China in energy and manufacturing; and within France itself, Marine Le Pen continues to pose a significant political challenge. Under such fragmented conditions, what basis does Europe have for declaring itself independent?

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882110705286155/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.