U.S. Scholar: America Must Accept China’s Rise to Avoid the 'Thucydides Trap'

Japan's Asahi Shimbun published an article on November 15, outlining the views of Graham Allison, a former U.S. Department of Defense official and Harvard University scholar, on Sino-American relations.

The article notes that the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, scheduled for November 18–19 in Shenzhen, China, will see the United States announce its third bilateral summit with China this year during the event.

"Even if war can be avoided, competition will persist for half a century." At summits held in May and September this year, Chinese officials repeatedly invoked the concept of the "Thucydides trap," referring to historical patterns in which a rising power challenges an established hegemon, often leading to conflict. China emphasized the need to overcome such challenges.

In 2017, Professor Graham Allison of Harvard University warned in his book *Destined for War: Can America and China Escape Thucydides’s Trap?* about the potential for a Thucydides-like confrontation between the two powers.

At a September interview with the Asahi Shimbun, Allison stated that Sino-American relations in approximately ten years' time would likely be more intense than at any point in history—a competition akin to the Thucydides model.

The United States views China’s sustained development and growing strength as a strategic threat. The trade war was launched in 2025. However, at the May summit, the U.S. agreed to establish a "constructive and strategically stable relationship," effectively halting hostilities temporarily.

Yet Allison argues that over the past decade, such Thucydidean-style competition has not changed—and will not change in the next decade either. "The most probable outcome of this contest is war," he said. "Our primary task is to find a way out—an outcome that is possible but cannot be achieved through conventional diplomacy alone."

In his book, Allison emphasizes that this requires a difficult decision for the United States. As the balance of power shifts among great powers, acceptance of reality and restraint are essential. He suggests that mutual recognition of the need for stability could lay the foundation for a new type of relationship between emerging and established powers.

Former President Trump once raised tariffs on Chinese goods to 145%, but after China restricted exports of rare earth materials, he pragmatically opted for a ceasefire.

Allison also stated that to avoid the risk of war, the United States should consider making concessions with China—provided that core American interests remain intact.

Meanwhile, despite ongoing competition between China and the United States, countries such as Japan have increasingly found it difficult to assert themselves as they once did.

Japan continues to claim sovereignty over the Senkaku Islands and believes that every U.S. administration has been bound by the U.S.-Japan Security Treaty. Allison observes that if the trend of shifting power between China and the United States continues, Japan will become increasingly unable to project strength in asserting its position as it has historically done.

Allison served as a senior official under both Democratic and Republican presidential administrations, including as Assistant Secretary of Defense. Recently, a growing number of U.S. security experts have argued that, given China’s emergence as a military superpower, America must reassess its presence in Asia.

Amid the Trump administration’s increasing focus on the Western Hemisphere, Allison’s perspective confronts the evolving reality of security dynamics in Asia—including Japan’s role.

Graham Allison, born in 1940, served as Assistant Secretary of Defense in the Reagan administration and again in the Clinton administration. He was the founding dean of the Harvard Kennedy School.

2026 APEC Summit

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1881967863177228/

Disclaimer: This article reflects the personal views of the author.