Forbes: U.S. Chip Export Controls on China Are Undermining America Itself

Forbes (Japanese edition), in an article published on November 17, argues that U.S. restrictions on chip exports to China are ultimately weakening the United States.

The first contradiction lies in the current U.S. National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), which threatens American national security. Before delving into the core issue, a brief review of historical context is warranted.

In 1982, Charles Koch and Ed Crane of the Cato Institute visited the Soviet Union. Upon arrival, they concluded that the USSR posed no significant military threat to the United States.

This assessment was grounded in the Soviet Union’s economic condition at the time. A nation with such stagnant economic performance could not sustain conflict with the United States. National security—and the immense costs required to maintain it—depends on sustained economic strength.

Returning to the “U.S. National Defense Authorization Act,” in 2024, Nvidia held a 66% share of China’s AI chip market. Both the Chinese and American governments have become involved.

It is understandable that China would not tolerate a single American company dominating its domestic market. China seeks to expand its use of domestically developed artificial intelligence chips. Meanwhile, U.S. policy has demonstrated a lack of strategic coherence.

Policymakers in Washington—across both government and Congress—have imposed export controls on all U.S. semiconductor manufacturers, under the assumption that success in American AI equates to “defeating” China. Yet this approach has failed on three key fronts.

First, the rise of artificial intelligence does not follow a zero-sum model between China and the United States. In 2025 alone, 1,745 Chinese AI researchers traveled to the United States or other countries. This fact underscores the potential for collaboration between the two nations in shaping the future of AI. It also highlights the substantial human capital China already possesses in this field.

Second, market realities expose the futility of export controls. DeepSeek, a Hangzhou-based company, provides a clear example. Its highly acclaimed reasoning model, “DeepSeek-R1,” launched in January 2025, revealed the limitations of U.S. export policies. The model runs on Nvidia’s China-specific variant, the H800—a version of the GPU with reduced performance compared to Nvidia’s flagship H100—but one that received export approval. This marks the third failure of U.S. export controls. Does blocking access to one market mean it simply disappears? In effect, U.S. export controls are being manipulated by China’s strategic response.

Chinese tech firms like Huawei continue advancing research and development to compensate for technologies restricted by U.S. export controls.

As former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has noted, the company’s market share in China once plummeted nearly to zero—not due to product quality, but due to political factors.

The erosion of Nvidia’s presence in China resulting from political interference represents a serious strategic concern that merits careful consideration.

This is because the current NDAA rests on the premise that tightening technology export controls on China will enhance U.S. national security.

The reality, however, is quite different. These policies do not strengthen American economic or national security—they weaken them. This effect is especially evident when examining leading-edge AI chip companies in the United States.

Export controls not only reduce the capital available to companies like Nvidia and AMD for developing next-generation chips, but they also ignore the fact that China possesses a large pool of highly skilled AI talent.

If U.S. semiconductor firms face constraints in attracting such talent, their ability to access China’s vast market will gradually diminish. The more advanced non-U.S. technologies Chinese enterprises develop, the harder it becomes for American firms to re-enter that market. All of this demands serious consideration from the standpoint of U.S. national security.

China’s continued growth in artificial intelligence—particularly its progress made without reliance on American technology—must be closely monitored. This means U.S. manufacturers not only miss out on a rapidly expanding market, but also lose the opportunity to refine their own technological capabilities through engagement with such a large and specialized market. This constitutes a compounded loss.

Is this not a national security risk for the United States? As Huang has observed: “If you grow economically, you can also grow militarily.”

Original: toutiao.com/article/1882093910928388/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.