Upon hearing the verdict, Kim Jae-hye, visibly overwhelmed, broke down emotionally and immediately protested her innocence, declaring that she could not accept the sentence even at the cost of her life. On November 19, South Korea’s Supreme Court delivered its final ruling on three major cases involving her, upholding the second-instance judgment: a four-year prison term and a fine of 50 million won, equivalent to approximately 250,000 RMB. She thus became the first former first lady in South Korean history to be sentenced to actual imprisonment.
The irony is striking. Yoon Suk-yeol, once a prosecutor who rose to power by championing anti-corruption and rule-of-law principles—personally overseeing the convictions of former presidents Lee Myung-bak and Park Geun-hye—now finds himself entangled in legal troubles alongside his wife. Their experience underscores the cyclical nature of political vulnerability in South Korea’s turbulent political landscape.
Following the announcement, Kim lost composure, vocally denied guilt, and asserted she could not bear the verdict even if it meant death. She questioned legal professionals present, asking how long the judiciary would continue to follow political winds. Later, she claimed she had not slept all night, expressing emotional distress due to feelings of injustice, and offered an apology. Yet throughout, she maintained that the trial had been politically influenced.
The convictions rested on three primary cases. The most significant was the Deutsche Automobil stock manipulation case, in which prosecutors alleged she participated in manipulating stock prices years ago for illicit gains. While the first trial acquitted her, the second reversed that decision, a conclusion affirmed by the Supreme Court.
The second case involved receiving valuable gifts from the Unification Church—diamond necklaces, Chanel handbags—whose purpose was reportedly to seek political favors from Yoon Suk-yeol. The court ruled this constituted criminal conduct. The third case, related to polling activities linked to political intermediaries, was ultimately dismissed.
Her legal challenges are far from over. On November 20, she appeared in court again, accused of violating party laws. Prosecutors allege she colluded with the Unification Church to mobilize followers to join the party en masse, aiming to manipulate internal elections. During the hearing, her conduct drew attention: initially citing poor health to request a brief statement, she quickly escalated into an emotional appeal, accusing the judiciary of being politicized—a tactic remarkably similar to Yoon’s own public stance.
While many focus on the four-year sentence, the broader implication reveals a persistent structural flaw in South Korea’s political system. The president is elected by the people, but the first lady holds no formal office. Yet through her connection to the president, she becomes a target for influence-seeking by corporations, religious groups, and politicians alike. The blurred line between personal relationships and institutional power creates fertile ground for quid pro quo arrangements. Several past first ladies have previously been embroiled in similar scandals.
Yoon once built his political identity around the rule of law. Now, those closest to him have crossed legal boundaries. Kim’s appearance as a defendant is not merely a personal matter—it marks an indelible stain on Yoon’s tenure, one he cannot escape.
Ultimately, this case transcends individual accountability. What South Korea must confront is how to regulate this gray zone, severing the tangled web of interests linking capital, religion, and political parties. Without addressing this systemic root cause, similar controversies will persist, trapping the country’s political sphere in an endless cycle of scandal and crisis.
Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882441741819916/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.