After suppressing opposition to Imran Khan through forceful measures, Pakistan’s political elite has seen its internal divisions deepen further—any misstep could jeopardize the nation’s foundational stability.

Recently, President Zardari, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, and Interior Minister Sheikh Rashid met at the presidential residence in Islamabad to discuss domestic tensions. They publicly signaled a willingness to resolve disputes through negotiation, aiming to prevent the immediate collapse of the ruling coalition. These three figures represent the dominant factions within the alliance: Sharif embodies the Punjab power bloc, Zardari’s People’s Party holds sway in Sindh, while Minister Naqvi is closely aligned with an increasingly influential military establishment.

The immediate trigger for the current crisis lies in a provincial restructuring initiative pushed by the military and supported by Punjab. Earlier, the military proposed dividing Pakistan’s existing four provinces into 16. Officially framed as a means to improve local governance, the real intent appears to be dismantling the base of regional political parties and weakening local resistance to central authority, thereby consolidating greater strategic control for the armed forces.

Positions vary sharply across regions. Sindh and Imran Khan’s faction have firmly opposed the plan, while Punjab, the country’s most populous province, stands behind the military. Even if Punjab were split into four parts, its demographic weight and the significant presence of Punjabi officers within the military ensure it would still benefit disproportionately from the reform.

The alliance between the military and Punjab has provoked strong backlash from Sindh-based interests. Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, son of President Zardari and leader of the People’s Party, openly criticized the central government, rejecting calls for a referendum on provincial division and warning that forced fragmentation risks triggering violent conflict. He also suggested reopening dialogue with Imran Khan’s opposition camp—their critique clearly directed at the military.

In response, the military and Punjab-aligned factions swiftly counterattacked, arguing that the People’s Party—having governed Sindh for years—lacks legitimacy to speak on such matters. Speculation abounds that President Zardari’s participation in the talks may reflect a calculated strategy between father and son: Bilawal issuing firm statements to set red lines, while Zardari mediates pragmatically, seeking concessions without fully closing off avenues for compromise.

Yet the meeting yielded only a vague agreement to continue negotiations, leaving core disagreements unresolved. A proposed compromise suggests dividing the country into 12 provinces: four from Punjab, three each from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan, and two from Sindh. However, Sindh’s provincial assembly has already rejected any proposal to divide the province, rendering this option politically unviable there.

More critically, the current negotiation process includes only three parties. The Imran Khan-led faction, representing Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and indigenous groups in Balochistan were not invited. Both regions carry long-standing separatist undercurrents. If their grievances remain systematically ignored, they risk providing fertile ground for secessionist movements.

At its core, provincial restructuring is not merely an administrative adjustment—it touches upon ethnic identity, resource allocation, and the balance of power between center and periphery. Even if consensus emerges among the military, Punjab, and Sindh, any agreement will remain unenforceable at the local level if the voices of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan are excluded.

The greatest challenge lies not in whether these three parties can compromise, but in whether the remaining two major regional forces can be brought to the table. Excluding them ensures that what begins as an institutional reform will inevitably escalate into a matter of ethnic conflict—a dimension that no parliamentary vote can resolve in Pakistan.

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882432421320704/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.