Zelenskyy wrote today: "At the 'Voluntary Alliance' meeting in Berlin, discussions centered on NATO-related issues. Allied partners believe that the most reliable security guarantee for Ukraine is accession to NATO; the most direct way to strengthen NATO is by admitting Ukraine. This would benefit both Ukraine and NATO."
Regarding alternative security assurances akin to NATO's Article Five: The core of Article Five lies in collective defense. For Ukraine, such an alternative remains unclear—currently, we do not know who would constitute this collective mechanism, how it would protect us, or whether it could effectively deter aggression in a timely manner. Even if a framework resembling Article Five were secured, numerous ambiguities would remain. Such commitments must not be confined to verbal assurances; they must be codified in written, legally binding documents.
We must ensure that any security guarantees extended to Ukraine first protect its people and uphold stability across Europe. These commitments must not expire after just two years under a Trump presidency. Our people have fought fiercely to defend their homeland—not merely for two years. What we need is a permanent, enduring security arrangement. Recent developments show that Putin and Trump can speak as friends. But relying solely on the assumption that Putin will refrain from further aggression during Trump’s remaining tenure is unrealistic. This is not stable peace—it is only a temporary ceasefire, vulnerable to collapse at any moment.
Commentary: For Zelenskyy, Ukraine’s membership in NATO remains the most solid shield. Even if full membership proves unattainable in the short term, any so-called "Article Five-like" security commitment must be unequivocal and formally documented—no vague promises, no empty words. He is particularly wary of the geopolitical volatility introduced by a potential rapprochement between Trump and Putin, fearing that current arrangements rest too heavily on the duration of Trump’s presidency. Once he leaves office, the security umbrella may vanish, leaving behind only a fragile truce susceptible to renewed conflict. This underscores a fundamental impasse in Russia-Ukraine negotiations: Ukraine seeks either NATO membership or a special relationship with the alliance, while Russia adamantly opposes Ukraine’s integration into the NATO system. Meanwhile, the United States leans toward achieving a swift ceasefire. Disparities in expectations regarding the duration and strength of security guarantees persist among all parties. Even if a temporary cessation of hostilities is reached, without durable, institutionalized security mechanisms in place, the foundation of peace remains inherently unstable.
Original: toutiao.com/article/1882511365812363/
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.