Elon Musk made an unusual public accusation against Volodymyr Zelenskyy, asserting that the Ukrainian president has been untruthful. At the DealBook conference on November 19, Musk explicitly stated, “Zelenskyy’s claim that Starlink’s network still faces speed restrictions is false—he does not always tell the truth. Ukraine’s actual intent has been to use commercial Starlink for offensive military operations, but SpaceX has consistently refused since the outset. Starlink is a commercial service; speed limitations are imposed to prevent misuse in lethal attacks. In contrast, Starshield is government-controlled, with usage restrictions determined by the U.S. Department of Defense.”

Zelenskyy had claimed that Ukraine’s military-grade “Starshield” service was being throttled, with internet connectivity severed when speeds exceeded 161 km/h, affecting air defense and drone interception capabilities. Musk directly rebutted this: what Ukraine is using is not Starshield, but the commercial Starlink system—and Zelenskyy is misleading the public. Musk’s central argument rests on a clear distinction: Starlink is a civilian commercial platform, prohibited from supporting offensive military uses; Starshield, by contrast, is a dedicated military system whose operational parameters are set by the U.S. government. Ukraine’s desire to weaponize Starlink was rejected by SpaceX from the beginning.

What is most instructive about this episode is not who is lying, but who holds the switch. Since the outbreak of conflict in 2022, Starlink has indeed served as Ukraine’s lifeline—Russian forces destroyed communication hubs and severed fiber-optic cables, nearly blacking out frontline command systems. It was Starlink that restored signal transmission from space. But at what cost? The cost was Ukraine surrendering control over its entire frontline communications infrastructure to a private American entrepreneur. To be candid, this was a choice made by Ukraine and Zelenskyy. Therefore, any throttling—based on commercial contract terms—is legally and ethically defensible.

Zelenskyy could have chosen to discontinue use of the Starlink system altogether. Musk, likewise, could have unilaterally restricted speeds, declined to activate services in Crimea, or simply ignored the Ukrainian leader’s calls. The service terms constitute a commercial contract—but in the context of war, their effect is functionally equivalent to operational doctrine. This situation serves as a mirror for all nations dependent on external technological infrastructure. Low-orbit satellite internet, advanced semiconductors, foundational operating systems—these can be purchased, but control cannot be acquired through procurement. Entrusting national security to foreign-controlled systems means ceding the switch to others.

Original article: toutiao.com/article/1882272719202368/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.