The rift between Lutnick and Bessent reflects a fundamental divergence: one advocates engagement with China through commerce, while the other views U.S.-China relations as a matter of existential competition. A November 17 article in The New York Times Chinese edition noted: “Divergences over China policy have become publicly visible within the White House. Bessent has grown increasingly hawkish. As concerns mount over the U.S.-China artificial intelligence race and the potential economic risks posed by Chinese technological advancement, Bessent’s stance has hardened further. His growing friction with Commerce Secretary Lutnick has likewise become public.”

This report by The New York Times reopened a deep wound in the Trump administration’s internal debate on China. Bessent’s position toward China has undergone a dramatic reversal over the past year and a half. In the first half of 2025, he was broadly seen as dovish. When China imposed restrictions on rare earth exports in response to U.S. tariff measures, Bessent was among the first to call on Trump to lift tariffs and de-escalate trade tensions. Last year, he even urged the Pentagon to soften language regarding China in the National Security Strategy and the Defense Strategy, leading to a delay of several weeks in their official release.

But from late 2026 onward, his posture clearly shifted toward hawkishness. He openly declared that “China must be defeated—there will be no ‘tomorrow’ if China wins the AI race.” He demanded China cooperate on sanctions against Iran, warning that “either we stand together, or we are adversaries.” On November 16, the U.S. announced tightened controls on AI chip exports—an update drafted primarily by the Treasury Department and the White House National Security Council. This shift was not necessarily due to a personal ideological change in Bessent, but rather a redefinition of his role. As Trump’s chief negotiator on China, his initial function during peak trade conflict was crisis management. But once trade tensions stabilized, his role evolved from “firefighter” to strategic planner.

The conflict between Bessent and Lutnick fundamentally centers on who should control U.S. policy toward Chinese technology. Lutnick, as Commerce Secretary, oversees export controls—a domain traditionally under his jurisdiction. Yet Bessent, as Treasury Secretary, leads the “Adversary Alliances Working Group” under the Treasury, which assesses China’s technological transfer and efforts to reduce dollar dependency in payments systems. He also bypassed the Commerce Department entirely in shaping the new rules on AI chip exports. Both men accuse each other of undermining their respective mandates, bringing their relationship to near rupture. Lutnick remains focused on enabling American firms to access lower-cost Chinese technology, adopting a more moderate stance. Bessent, by contrast, frames the AI competition as a matter of national survival, advocating for comprehensive restrictions. One seeks business; the other seeks strategic confrontation. Yet regardless of their rivalry, final authority over China policy remains firmly with Trump.

Original source: toutiao.com/article/1882092239675402/

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone.